Tuesday, January 31, 2006

Assignment 2 - Due Sunday February 5 Noon
1. Please read the Net.Art and Net.Pedagogy* handout & Text book Introduction and post your 1 page reflection here.
*You must refer to at least 3 other examples of Internet Art and include all URL hyperlinks in your posting. Also, please visit your classmates' blogs and add comments to each.
2. Please open the Museum Education beta test site link and complete the emailed usability survey - then kindly return it to me with your initials on the file name.
**Reminder**Online Class next week February 6***that assignment now on BlackBoard Check your email for login info!

3 comments:

Pete said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Pete said...

I think it is interesting that some students felt that sites with text were automatically not fine art. Art is more about media and content to these children, not concepts. I liked the student who said art is “pictures without explanations that make you think”.
Some personal websites I’ve seen are so strange that they are easier to describe, and critique as works of art rather than “regular websites”. I think it would be interesting to use Colman’s list of aesthetic qualities, and apply them to websites that are not intended to be fine art. Children will gain much from this practice, being able to critically deconstruct websites should be a lesson plan in and of itself.
I guess you could make visual art for the Playstation, or video iPod. An aesthetic puzzle I would present to a classroom is, “Are some video games fine art, and if so why?”
Superbadis a good example of pictures without explanations that make you think. Salad Fingers is a Flash animation that is creepy as all get out. I think it must be art because it makes me so upset and uncomfortable. Falling woman this site is weird, you can dislodge the falling woman with your mouse if she gets stuck, aside from that I don’t know what to tell you.

Anonymous said...

I read Alison Colman’s Research Article with an open, yet admittedly cynical frame of mind. It was with mixed emotions that I reflected upon the internet artwork that we viewed in the previous week’s class. While Olia Lialina’s “My Boyfriend Came Back from the War” held my attention and my intrigue, the conceptually based work of Paesmans and Heemskirk (“Jodi.org”) was less endearing to my personal tastes and appreciation. My skepticism towards their work is maybe a reflection of my own juvenile type attitude, as the reasons the secondary students in the article didn’t initially appreciate the artwork virtually mirrored my own reasons.
Similarly to the secondary students in the research population, I felt disoriented upon viewing much of the internet artwork, and frankly, I would be challenged to interpret much of it, much less critique it. But I am from a generation that, as stated in a song from the post-Dead Milkmen locally based band The Low Budgets, “Born Before the Internet.” So as I explored Colman’s research, I wondered if these modern day secondary students would get it. Apparently not, as the students evidently “shut down” and did “poorly” on the worksheets that Colman passed out to them after their first viewing of the websites. I found the following quote from the article particularly interesting. “Several students also initially disliked Internet art because they felt it did not resemble other art forms or that it was not sufficiently artistic.” (Colman, 2004) It is interesting to me that the students rejected the work originally upon viewing it. We are dealing with a population of people that were born into an age of computers that were raised on email and websites and instant messaging. Yet they still seem to be attracted to artwork that is aesthetically compelling, and perhaps pleasing to the eye, be it a pleasure that is of a beautiful nature or that of a conceptually thought provoking nature. Without the teacher’s “guidance,” they didn’t seem to know how to look at it or WHY to look at it. This brings me to two points from which my skepticism draws forth from.
1. The intended audience of internet art could marginalize the potential group of people interested in spending time viewing it. For example, the work of “Jodi.org” intrigued some of us in class, while others didn’t know what to do with it. Some of us felt that there was something wrong with our computers as numerous windows flickered throughout our monitors. I shared this website with some friends outside of the UArts environment and their attention could best be described as “fleeting.” Within the article, Paesmans and Heemskirk were cited as having spent time in Silicon Valley, observing computer programmers. Their work was noted to be of a reactionary nature against the attack of commercialization upon the internet. The artists considered the programmers to be the frontline soldiers in that war. To quote Heemskirk, “it is a bit of a personal matter to turn Netscape inside out…” (Colman, 2004) I would venture to say that the majority of Heemskirks audience has not themselves personally traveled to Silicon Valley to view the computer programmers in action. And the nature of their work suggests that maybe the computer programmers themselves would be the better intended audience. Otherwise, I felt that their statement against the commercialization of the internet was too abstract to attract the casual viewer of art, the average person on the street, who has not been formally guided as to how to interpret and appreciate internet art.
2. That brings me to my second notion that internet art may reside in a forum that is not conducive to the average person’s appreciation of artwork in its traditional appeal. Someone may walk down the street and gaze at a mural anywhere in the city and be able to determine the appeal of a colorful arrangement of tiles and mirrors versus the terrifying and Lenin-like portrait of a Frank Rizzo mural. They may stop to gaze at a sculpture on